Core returns HTTP 400, where XI returns 302 or 200

[dlukinski]

Hello Nagios Support

I get CORE HTTP checks returning HTTP 400, where XI returns 302 for the same check command

CORE:
FI-HVK-NRDP-HTTP-Login-tracker.konecranes.com

WARNING 02-21-2018 23:24:02 0d 0h 48m 51s 5/5 HTTP WARNING: HTTP/1.1 400 Bad Request - 581 bytes in 0.005 second response time

XI:

HTTP OK: HTTP/1.1 200 200 - 40883 bytes in 0.035 second response time

Command:
check_xi_service_http! -f follow -I 10.102.74.221 -u "/" -S -p 443!!!!!!!

check_http in CORE case

How to fix this?

[tacolover101]

check_xi_service_http is likely defined different than your check_http. i would compare your check commands.

if that's not the case, chase down all the differences and you'll eventually find one. running check_http / curl in verbose will help.

[scottwilkerson]

I agree with @tacolover101, you will need to compare the commands as will as the check_command in the config for each of them and compare side by side.

[dlukinski]

I agree with @tacolover101, you will need to compare the commands as will as the check_command in the config for each of them and compare side by side.

Could we transfer check_xi to CORE, rename and use it as check_http2 ?

Both XI and CORE http are the stock ones (never edited)

[scottwilkerson]

I am not sure what you mean by check_xi

[dlukinski]

I am not sure what you mean by check_xi

Either copy check_xi_service_http and rename to check_http2 or copy check_http from XI machine to CORE?

[scottwilkerson]

sure that would work

[dlukinski]

sure that would work

Copied check_http from XI to CORE (called check_http2, configured in commands)

Tried using with 3 portals checks
- same commands used as in XI
- same check_http used as in XI

WARNING in CORE and OK in XI

So this is not check_http problem, but a CORE server problem. We;ve got 8 of them checking portals remotely and we want to see this problem fixed.

What we do now?

[scottwilkerson]

can you show the command line output and the command, running the command from the CLI?


I also need you to share the command, service and host config both on a working systen and a non-working system

If it

[dlukinski]

can you show the command line output and the command, running the command from the CLI?


I also need you to share the command, service and host config both on a working systen and a non-working system

If it

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Case of 3 VPN Portal checks (same command, different IPs)

Code: Select all

 -f follow -I 185.15.212.41 -u "/" -S -p 443

OK in XI CLI

Code: Select all

[nagios@fikc-nagxiprod01.konecranes.com ~]$ /usr/local/nagios/libexec/check_http -H vpneur.konecranes.com -f follow -I 185.15.212.41 -u "/" -S -p 443
HTTP OK: HTTP/1.1 200 OK - 7426 bytes in 0.113 second response time |time=0.112642s;;;0.000000 size=7426B;;;0

OK in CORE CLI

Code: Select all

[root@fikc-hvk-nagcore01 objects]# /usr/local/nagios/libexec/check_http -H vpneur.konecranes.com -f follow -I 185.15.212.41 -u "/" -S -p 443
HTTP OK: HTTP/1.1 200 OK - 7426 bytes in 0.131 second response time |time=0.130780s;;;0.000000 size=7426B;;;0

- Tried both "core" check_http and "xi" check_http on the CORE with the same command.

BUT WARNING in CORE GUI as attached