There might be something goofy going on with the postgres sequences, XI has a similar error show up from time to time. I'll take a look at the XI fix and see if I can come up with something comparable for Fusion (if it's not already there).
Give this script a try and see if it takes care of the issue. Place it in your /usr/local/nagiosfusion/scripts directory and add executable permissions.
You do not have the required permissions to view the files attached to this post.