Re: [Nagios-devel] Nagios Interoperability
Posted: Tue Aug 30, 2005 11:02 pm
Andreas Ericsson wrote:
> sean finney wrote:
>
>>
>> i guess that's a little tricky. from my experience, though, if the=20
>> schema
>> definition already existed, or was seperately released and developed,
>> you wouldn't be breaking any licenses merely providing compatibility
>> with said definitions.=20
>
>
> Think client-server exchange. Webbrowsers wouldn't have to be GPL'd=20
> even if Apache was. This is basically the same thing.
>
That's because the HTTP, FTP, ... protocols are not covered by the GPL=20
.Rather, they are in the public domain and are established after RFCs=20
have been written and reviewed by a group of people (namely, companies=20
and opensource groups).
In our case, I'm not against writing a protocol for sending Nagios=20
information over the network; in fact I've already done so (in part).=20
What would be important to define is whether the structures of Nagios=20
could be exposed through that definition.
>> On Tue, Aug 30, 2005 at 04:34:11PM +0200, Thibault Genessay wrote:
>>
>>>> What about the most simple solution: get a proper license from Ethan=
.
>>>> The GPL is the default license, Ethan can give you a custom license =
if
>>>> he wants to.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Why not after all ... But I doubt Ethan would allow such a license=20
>>> just for me (and actually I see no reason why I could do something=20
>>> the others cannot). Anyway I think that it would be an improvement=20
>>> to open a few of the specs. of Nagios through the use of an LGPL=20
>>> shared lib.
>>
>>
>>
>> i can't speak for anyone but myself... but if someone came along to me
>> wanting an alternate license for a gpl'd project of mine, there's a
>> chance i could be persuaded to do so if there were some personal
>> incentive
>>
>
> Money, money, money. It's so foney (?). It's a hackers world.
>
I know a few nice restaurants nearby which serve the famous grenouilles=20
saut=E9es au beurre and the incredible poulet de Bresse aux morilles, le=20
tout arros=E9 d'un petit Saint-V=E9ran dont vous me direz des nouvelles;=20
after what I think nothing can be refused.
--=20
Thibault GENESSAY
ALIADIS
www.aliadis.fr
Tel. +(33) 870 723 724
Fax +(33) 4 72 13 90 40
This post was automatically imported from historical nagios-devel mailing list archives
Original poster: [email protected]
> sean finney wrote:
>
>>
>> i guess that's a little tricky. from my experience, though, if the=20
>> schema
>> definition already existed, or was seperately released and developed,
>> you wouldn't be breaking any licenses merely providing compatibility
>> with said definitions.=20
>
>
> Think client-server exchange. Webbrowsers wouldn't have to be GPL'd=20
> even if Apache was. This is basically the same thing.
>
That's because the HTTP, FTP, ... protocols are not covered by the GPL=20
.Rather, they are in the public domain and are established after RFCs=20
have been written and reviewed by a group of people (namely, companies=20
and opensource groups).
In our case, I'm not against writing a protocol for sending Nagios=20
information over the network; in fact I've already done so (in part).=20
What would be important to define is whether the structures of Nagios=20
could be exposed through that definition.
>> On Tue, Aug 30, 2005 at 04:34:11PM +0200, Thibault Genessay wrote:
>>
>>>> What about the most simple solution: get a proper license from Ethan=
.
>>>> The GPL is the default license, Ethan can give you a custom license =
if
>>>> he wants to.
>>>>
>>>
>>> Why not after all ... But I doubt Ethan would allow such a license=20
>>> just for me (and actually I see no reason why I could do something=20
>>> the others cannot). Anyway I think that it would be an improvement=20
>>> to open a few of the specs. of Nagios through the use of an LGPL=20
>>> shared lib.
>>
>>
>>
>> i can't speak for anyone but myself... but if someone came along to me
>> wanting an alternate license for a gpl'd project of mine, there's a
>> chance i could be persuaded to do so if there were some personal
>> incentive
>>
>
> Money, money, money. It's so foney (?). It's a hackers world.
>
I know a few nice restaurants nearby which serve the famous grenouilles=20
saut=E9es au beurre and the incredible poulet de Bresse aux morilles, le=20
tout arros=E9 d'un petit Saint-V=E9ran dont vous me direz des nouvelles;=20
after what I think nothing can be refused.
--=20
Thibault GENESSAY
ALIADIS
www.aliadis.fr
Tel. +(33) 870 723 724
Fax +(33) 4 72 13 90 40
This post was automatically imported from historical nagios-devel mailing list archives
Original poster: [email protected]